2 white whales! Topps Golden Spikes

4 01 2015

I found 2 cards on eBay last month that I’ve been looking for quite a while now.  As part of my Lifetime Topps project, I collect every base card from 1980-2009 Topps flagship.  I also collect every insert card within reason.  Reason isn’t really something I’ve ever defined – and I haven’t had to quite yet since I’m only to 2000.  But it basically excluded parallels, autos, relics or inserts that are numbered.  Last, I also collect promo cards.  Topps produced pre-production cards from 1991 to (I think) 2007.  I’m collecting all of those.  They aren’t all that hard to find if I just pay attention to eBay here and there.

But one other group of promo cards existed for the 1991-1994 set, and has proven very difficult to flag down for me.  In November each year, Topps would host the Golden Spikes award banquet for the best player in amateur baseball.  Bob Horner was the first winner in 1978, and AJ Reed, who was drafted last year by the Astros, was the most recent winner.  The list of winners is actually very impressive from an MLB career perspective.  There aren’t any Hall of Famers to come out of the list yet, but that could change.  Will Clark probably had the best career of any player to win the award.  There have also been a number of future award winners:

  • Buster Posey (MVP),
  • Tim Lincecum and David Price (Cy Young),
  • Horner, Jason Jennings, Posey and Bryce Harper (Rookie of the Year)
  • Tim Wallach (Comeback PoY)

Lincecum, Jered Weaver and Jim Abbott threw no-hitters.  2 guys – Robin Ventura and Terry Francona – are current MLB managers.  Stephen Strasburg and Alex Gordon are current MLB stars.

The 1990-1993 winners were immortalized on cardboard by Topps, in each case done in a way to preview the next year’s flagship set design.  The cards were given out at the November banquet, and supposedly there are ~600 in existence.  The 4 winners from those years are not as impressive as any of the names above, though Fernandez did have a nice career.

  • 1990 – Alex Fernandez (1991 Topps)
  • 1991 – Mike Kelly (1992 Topps)
  • 1992 – Phil Nevin (1993 Topps)
  • 1993 – Darren Dreifort (1994 Topps)

I picked up the Fernandez card a few years ago.  Last month, I found the Kelly and Nevin on eBay for the first time, and was quick to pick up both.  The Kelly didn’t cost me too much, but I did pay over 50 bucks for the Nevin.  Since I’d never seen it, I was glad to get it.  I kind of figured I’d never see these cards, so now I’ve only got the Dreifort and I’d have all of them.  Maybe at some point I’ll find it.  There was an autographed card for sale on eBay, but I don’t want a signed card, and it was way too expensive even if I did want it.

Here’s scans of the front and back.  I’ve updated my pre-production posts from 1992 and 1993 Topps.  Here are scans of the fronts and backs of these cards.

1993 Topps Golden Spikes Phil Nevin 1993 Topps Golden Spikes Phil Nevin back 1992 Topps Golden Spikes Mike Kelly 1992 Topps Golden Spikes Mike Kelly back

And the Fernandez thrown in to boot.

1990 Topps Debut Promo Alex Fernandez




11 responses

5 01 2015

Congrats! Those are great cards. I’ve long wanted the Mike Kelly for my Braves collection.

5 01 2015

Thanks – I’ve actually got a 2nd one if you’re up to do a trade. 2 came up on eBay at the same time, and I put in winning bids on both.

18 07 2022

U have the golden spikes still ?


5 01 2015

What are you looking for in trade?

5 01 2015

Or shall I say, how much in trade? I forgot about your wantlists- duh!

6 01 2015

Nothing too crazy – I think I paid around 15, including shipping. So whatever you think is fair – I’m happy to help you out, it’s a tough card to find at times, and I just bid on 2 to ensure I got at least 1!

8 01 2015

So, I found quite a few that are on your Topps Inserts list (I don’t break much wax, so am limited on stuff like that):
2014 Super Veteran #3 Jeter,
2010 Red Backs :6 Cy Young, 8 Mo Rivera, 11 Lou Gehrig
2013 ’71 Minis #50 Machado
2014 ’89 Minis #43 Mauer, 96Teixeira
2014 Upper Clas #11 Freese
2014 Future/Now #39 Wong
2014 Making/Mark #31 Zunino
2014 Breakout Season #10 Shields
2013 Chasing/History #130 Jackie Robinson, 147 Bob Feller and 148 Machado

If that wouldn’t be enough, if you can let me know if there’s any players you collect, or?


8 01 2015

That works – can you shoot me an email? charliemowry24 (gmail)

8 01 2015


17 01 2015
Chopping Cards | Lifetime Topps project

[…] I completed a few trades recently, and one of them was with Steve from the Card Chop.  I sent Steve a Mike Kelly Golden Spikes card that I’d purchased an extra one on eBay. […]

27 08 2015
Another white whale! Darren Dreifort’s Topps Golden Spikes card | Lifetime Topps project

[…] found the 1991 card (for 1990 Golden Spikes winner) of Alex Fernandez about 3 years ago.  Earlier this year, I found the 1992 card for ’91 winner Mike Kelly and the 1993 card for ’92 winner Phil […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: